Rich Fitzgerald Provides Guidance for Assessments Appeals

Deadline to appeal is April 2.

With the deadline to file a formal appeal on assessments fast approaching, Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald is holding informational meetings throughout the region.

The first was held Wednesday at Baldwin High School, and Fitzgerald held another Thursday evening at Brashear High School with Pittsburgh City Council member James Ellenbogen.

Similar meetings will be held in all 13 Allegheny County districts to help people prepare for an appeals process that many hope will lower their assessments.

The deadline to make a formal appeal on the assessments is April 2. The form to do so is available online or by visiting the Office of Property Assessments. The deadline to schedule an informal review has passed, but those who have already taken that route can still file a formal appeal.

"One judge overruled and took the policy-making away from elected officials," said Fitzgerald, who has been an outspoken opponent of the reassessments process. "We're the only county out of 67 in Pennsylvania to have a court-ordered reassessment."

Assessments will determine 2013 property taxes, but each town's by law so that local officials don't collect excess taxes.

If a property owner's 2013 court-ordered reassessment value is lower than the average of his or her municipality, school district or the county, he or she should see a reduction in the corresponding municipal, school district or county property tax in 2013.

But if a property's owner's reassessment value is higher than the average of his or her municipality, school district or the county, he or she may see an increase in the corresponding municipal, school district or county property tax in 2013.

Allegheny County's average increase is 35 percent.

Melinda Freed, a professional speaker hired by the county—and a homeowner appealing her own assessment—presented details on the reassessments and appeals process at the Baldwin meeting.

She said the No. 1 factor affecting an individual assessment is location. Also considered by county assessors were variables like square footage, lot size, age, grade, condition and number of rooms, bathrooms, fireplaces, garage spaces and more.

When deciding whether or not to appeal an assessment, Freed spoke of three key questions to consider:

  1. Is my property information correct? If not, you can submit changes online or call the county assessments office at 412-350-4600 to provide correct information.
  2. Could I sell my house for this amount? Recent sales nearby are the best evidence for this, and a real estate professional may be able to help sellers get an idea of the fair market values of their properties.
  3. Am I being treated fairly? Each property is assessed based on comparable properties in its area that were sold between January 2009 and March 2011. If your property is assessed higher than those other properties and is below the condition or characteristics of those properties, you should file an appeal.

If you do appeal, Freed said that the best way to prepare for an appeal hearing is to gather concrete evidence—like recent sales records, a certified appraisal, mortgage documents and photos—to present your case. She advised property owners to bring three hard copies of everything at the time of their hearings.

The formal appeals process differs from the informal reviews process. A formal appeal will be recorded, and representatives from a particular property's school district and municipality will have an opportunity to attend the appeal (as well make appeals). No decision will be made at the actual time of a hearing, as news of its outcome will be sent by mail.

Those that disagree with the outcome of their appeals can take the process higher and appeal to the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas within 30 days. The common pleas appeal costs approximately $103 for property owners, school districts and municipalities alike.

Three more town hall meetings will be held:

  • April 2, 7 p.m. - CCAC Allegheny Campus, 808 Ridge Avenue, Pittsburgh
  • April 4, 7 p.m. - Chartiers Valley Intermediate School, 2030 Swallow Hill Road, Scott Twp.
  • April 12, 7 p.m. - Shaler Area High School, 381 Wible Run Road, Shaler Twp.

Will you be appealing? Are you satisfied with your assessment? Tell us in the comments section below.

Follow Dormont-Brookline Patch on Facebook and Twitter. For more news, sign up for our email Newsletter.

John Spoon March 30, 2012 at 02:10 PM
Allegheny County's average increase is 35%. Dormont went up avg 53 & KO 50. My property went up 59. This is absolutely insane for Dormont. I was at the meeting & I need clarity on something (wish there was a recording of Fitzgerald's answer to this) If you win your hearing the county will not appeal the decision but that's not saying the municipality and/or school district won't and if they do the 103$ that I would have to pay out of pocket if I lost and appealed would be paid by the taxpayers. Its absurd that my house, which I purchased in the last few years, is listed as a comparable to itself. One neighbors house, which is a cookie cutter design and we have the same land, is 20k less than mine but its not "comparable". Then Fitzgerald said we should take pictures of our neighbors houses/land. There was a lot of contradicting going on that made my head spin. I felt like he was looking for a pat on the back because he had this pushed to 2013. He made comments about how someone running for re-election is helping him fight the reassessment and we should remember that in November (thought that was uncalled for). He also said he didn't want to be there but had to. Rich said people walked the streets and evaluated each piece of property to help determine value. He said they took recent sales into consideration too. I find that bull when a 3 story house that sold for 30k more than mine recently, has new siding, porch, & garage is valued 20k less than me.
John Spoon March 30, 2012 at 02:18 PM
I'm just having a hard time understanding how something like this is even happening when the economy is in toilet. The thought of selling my first home because of such a backwards process blows my mind. They never even saw the inside of my house and the work it needs, they just eyeballed it and figured it went up in value. My hearing is in April and I'm going in with as many pictures as I can handle and my fingers crossed.
dormonter March 30, 2012 at 11:11 PM
Did anyone thank Rich Fitzgerald for the tax increase of 25% that we have to pay THIS year? Can we appeal that too???


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »