.
Feedback

Illegal Immigration

Why Amnesty?

AJ’S Corner

Anthony P. Joseph, Jr.

            To begin with, what is the definition of ILLEGAL?  To quote from Merriam Webster’s Online Dictionary, the definition of illegal is quite obvious; “not according to or authorized by law”. 

            Over the years, and various presidents, attempts were made, and at times with some success, to make illegal immigrants legal via the amnesty route.  After all since they are working here anyway, paying taxes anyway, and being education anyway, why not make the illegal immigrants citizens.  What is the fallacy in this argument?   A complete injustice and mockery is done to those immigrants who are legally in the United States; and who are working here, paying taxes here and being educated here; AND who want to become citizens via the legal process.

            Why are politicians so anxious to wipe out the illegal status and give the illegal immigrants a pass?  Why are the politicians complicit in destroying a workable immigration process that has served the country for decades?  The push for the Dreams Act is a polite way of negating what the United States means.  The Dreams Act will give permanent residency to certain illegal individuals of good moral character, what are the parameters of a good moral character?  An illegal who graduated from high school, why are illegal’s getting a free education? An illegal who has live in the United States for at least 5 years, continuously; if authorities know this person is illegal how is it that this person is living in the U.S. for so long? An illegal who has completed 2 years of military service; why is this person in the military?  An illegal who has completed 2 years at a 4 year institution; who is paying for this education?  The Dream Act list goes on. 

 

            Just recently, the Supreme Court has ruled against several provision of the Arizona’s immigration laws.  Two concerns come to mind; first, since the Supreme Court ruled on a state’s law, how will other states view this ruling; second, why is there a constitutional question concerning illegal immigrants; THEY ARE NOT CITIZENS!

 

            Again you have to answer the question, why is there a push for amnesty?  What political gain is there? 

 

            Most importantly, what part of illegal do you not understand?

            LATER

            AJ        

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Dormont-Brookline Patch? Find your Local Patch »

MSgt. John DeLallo July 2, 2012 at 12:36 pm
Anthony:
You hit a real hot button with me. First, its now politically incorrect to talk about illegal immigrants. Rep. Cruz from Philadelphia, on the house floor, chastized everyone that illegal aliens would have to be from another planet, and aligned himself (surprise) with them. Thank God for Daryl Metcalfe. He's pushed some legislation through that will make sure PA is not a sanctuary state. You ask why the push for amnesty, put forth as an executive order after the DREAM act failed? Votes, my friend, votes. With amnesty will come suffrage--and very likely more welfare rats. Still wondering about Voter I.D.? There sure seems to be a lot of outrage over a "problem that does not exist". Both my maternal and paternal grandparents came here after the European economy collapsed just after WWI. They came legally, learned English, got their citizenship, and their sons went off to WWII to fight the "home" countries of Italy and Germany. A PROCESS EXISTS TO LEGALLY COME HERE! 11 million "undocumented workers"? Its way out of hand, I believe.
Mike July 2, 2012 at 12:42 pm
The question you have to ask is who is taking advantage of these 11 million undocumented workers.
Someone is paying them to do a job , otherwise they wouldn't bother coming to our country. Who are these job creators that are making profits by not hiring legal Americans?
MSgt. John DeLallo July 2, 2012 at 01:03 pm
Point very well taken, Mike. If Government made it very, very, unnattactive to hire illegals (undocumented workers if you like--I don't), the number of jobs available to illegals would shrink, and perhaps illegal immigration may slow down.
Ed M July 2, 2012 at 02:10 pm
Here's my take.
If they are here illegally, the minimal wages they are getting paid are probably not taxed. And since the wages are minimal, they are not really generating very much tax, if any, on their spending. The end result is they are a drain on everyone else. I'm also wondering how it's unconstitutional to do anything to illegal aliens. They are not citizens. The Constitution doesn't apply to them!
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Johann Lynge June 13, 2013 at 03:54 am
@MCG - I appreciate how you perceived the situation and I apologize if that was in fact the case.Read More Like I said I was not privy to the exact conversation. However at the time it wasn't explained like that to me so I was unaware and handled it as I interpreted it. My apologies if I was mistaken.
Johann Lynge June 13, 2013 at 04:07 am
@Debbie L. Actually the police have not been to the pub in a long time. The last time they wereRead More there was because I called them because a man who was intoxicated (which we didn't serve because he is barred) came in and refused to leave. And I don't ever recall seeing the fire department there. But to blame it on the Pub is a misconception because even if you closed the pub there are half a dozen other bars on the blvd that everyone would then frequent. While Bob Dobbs recommendation of reinstating prohibition might sound like a good idea good luck with that. Prohibition didn't prevent drinking in the 20's and it wouldn't stop it now either. Ultimately we can not make everyone happy but we do our best to run a safe and friendly establishment. And I make it my personal mission to prevent any and all fights. Since I've been the door man (almost 6 months) we have only had 1 fight in the bar which was quickly broken up. We are not perfect. Nor is any other bar. But we constantly strive to make improvements. We are a community pub. We love our community and everyone in it.
Bob Dobbs June 13, 2013 at 01:23 pm
i should say that out of the handful of bars in the vicinity, i prefer the brookline pub if i'mRead More gonna go to a bar . i dont care for the younger kids that accumulate on saturday nights with that annoying ghetto music but the food specials are decent and they do stock a decent selection of beers . i find zippy's to be much more clique-y and narrow-minded .
Brad Birdwell June 10, 2013 at 09:18 pm
@Daria. My description is 100% accurate. Yes, the bouncer quickly handled the situation by claimingRead More he witnessed "the whole thing". And he did. He witnessed my friends and I waiting to order a drink. That's all. Nothing more. Nothing less. The description is not harsh, it's actually toned down in comparison to what actually happened. The bouncer said, "I witnessed the whole thing and you were being a ****. One customer standing in line to order. One customer flicking another customer's hood and getting in his face. Which one was wrong? Apparently me since I don't go there frequently.
Johann Lynge June 11, 2013 at 08:39 am
To everyone following this thread, I'm the doorman in question at the Brookline Pub. I've posted aRead More response to the original poster on Patch.com that can be found at the following address: http://dormont-brookline.patch.com/groups/opinion/p/in-response-to-the-post-brookline-pubhorrible-experience I implore everyone to read that response to hear my side of the story. Thank you.
Debbie L. June 12, 2013 at 09:36 pm
Brad,,i totally agree with ya 100 percent,,nothing but trouble there, when my son starts going thereRead More from time to time again, i know hes up to no good.
Erin Faulk (Editor) June 8, 2013 at 06:08 pm
Thanks for adding this, Drew! Article coming soon. If you have any photos from the games, pleaseRead More feel free to add the photos here, too.
Drew Lehman June 9, 2013 at 10:08 am
The game actually will be played at Green Twp. Park in Scotland Pa. (near Chambersburg)
JLMK June 8, 2013 at 01:36 pm
Hi there. My fiancee and i are interested. Can you inbox me? Jesskrchmar@Gmail. Com
coreylahey June 5, 2013 at 05:51 pm
But I reported on documented actions that happened within the community. Where is the violation?
Erin Faulk (Editor) June 5, 2013 at 05:54 pm
One was removed for personal attacks, another because it implied that there was corruption by aRead More specific person. Although you didn't name the person, it was implied. Since the corruption was never proven, I removed the comment. It's over. You're welcome to continue commenting as long as you follow the term of use.
coreylahey June 6, 2013 at 12:25 am
Yeah I guess the public online court records showing someone pleading guilty is not proof